The good, the bad, and the unexpected of purchasing an auto repair shop

John Phelps

|

August 29, 2024

|

Read time: 3 min

Whether you’ve worked in the industry for years as a technician or are considering moving into the automotive industry for the first time, owning an auto repair shop can be a very rewarding experience.

In collaboration with PartsTech, we reached out to our customer, Eric Reich, who purchased his auto shop in 2021, to learn about his experience and share it with you. 

Before becoming an auto repair shop owner, Eric worked for about ten years in the aerospace MRO (Maintenance, Repair & Overhaul) sector and about ten years in the electrical distribution sector. Looking for a change, Eric ultimately jumped into the auto repair industry by purchasing Bennet’s Automotive — a six-bay shop that services all domestic and Asian-manufactured vehicles.

The Dream: Owning his own business

For Eric, working at large corporations for 20 years became too predictably bureaucratic. He felt buried by meetings, paperwork, and slow decision-making. “After spending nearly two decades at corporate companies, I was looking for something I could call my own,” said Eric. “My goal was to be an independent business owner and not rely on large corporations whose only goal was to maximize profits at all costs. I found that independence when I purchased Bennett's Automotive, which has been in business since 1991.”

The Good: Success and positive outcomes

Taking the time to find the right shop 

Eric didn’t want just to purchase the first shop for sale that came across his path, “You can’t rush or predetermine anything. If the shop you are evaluating is not a good candidate, then you have to walk away,” said Eric. During his patient search, Eric found that he very much enjoyed the process of evaluating prospective shops and identifying if they were a good potential candidate to achieve his business goals. 

A dedicated, expert team

From our conversation with Eric, it is clear that he values his team, which stayed on through the change of ownership when he purchased the shop. “I have been consistently impressed and proud of my team's dedication and technical expertise. During the transition of ownership, they did not allow the uncertainty of the situation to impact the quality of their work,” said Eric. Having the right people in place is critical to a successful shop. “I was so lucky to purchase a shop with such a solid existing team.”

The Bad: Challenges and setbacks

A small team naturally results in staffing issues

Eric credits his team with minimizing the level of operational challenges he faced as a first-time shop owner: “Thankfully, I had a great core team when I took over the shop. Without them, the transition would have been much more difficult. You are only as good as your team.”

Though his team is awesome, he quickly discovered that his most significant operational challenge would be staffing: “As a smaller shop, the risk is in quality manpower. If we have a guy out or are operating a guy short, it adds additional strain to the rest of the team.”

The Unexpected: The things that caught Eric off guard 

Time is incredibly precious, and everyone wants a piece of it

“As a shop owner, you have to be careful about your time,” says Eric, “and one of the biggest surprises I encountered was the number of unsolicited calls from random companies trying to sell or sign me up for something.” 

There is a ton of paperwork.

“I did not realize how much paperwork would come with purchasing and owning a shop,” said Eric, “There is a lot!” 

Tips from Eric for anyone interested in purchasing an existing auto shop 

First things first 

Before jumping into the deep end of purchasing a shop, Eric recommends you consider the following first:

  • Be very honest with yourself regarding your goals. Do you want to work in the shop? Be more hands-off? Etc.
  • Be willing to walk away from a bad deal. Don't get attached to any one shop/location. If the numbers don't make sense, don't move forward.
  • Ensure you have enough operating cash. You must have enough cash to handle normal ebbs and flows and an emergency. Not having enough cash is the fastest way to run into problems. (Eric likes to have at least three months of overhead.)
  • Be very thoughtful about overhead. You have to ensure that each overhead line item has a specific and defined purpose. 
  • Take training in basic financial acumen. To be set up for success when starting the journey of purchasing a shop, Eric advises aspiring shop owners to have a strong understanding of business finances such as P&Ls, pricing strategies, and cash flows to evaluate the shop's health. This is important so you know whether or not you should walk away from a deal. If necessary, Eric encourages taking a financial training course first.

It’s not just about the physical tools and equipment.

When purchasing an existing shop that already had a lot of the necessary physical tools and equipment, Eric focused on the software he wanted to implement. He encourages shop owners to evaluate the current software and make necessary changes early in their ownership journey. 

Choose software that drives efficiency and organization and is user-friendly for employees. Also, select software that enhances customer engagement and provides a positive experience.

“Generally, you must streamline your operations and communicate effectively with customers. We use Tekmetric as our shop management software for efficient workflow and customer communication. It also integrates with software such as PartsTech, which allows us to quickly source, price, and order parts from multiple vendors. This efficiency helps our small shop operate as lean as possible, speeding up vehicle repairs.”

Put a big focus on building trust with customers

One of the big reasons Eric wanted to upgrade the shop's software when he purchased it was to have better tools to help build customer trust. “We transitioned to Tekmetric from an older legacy program that made communicating via text/electronically almost impossible. We get consistent customer feedback that they like our new system and communication method with our ability to send inspections, images, videos, estimates, and invoices digitally.”

Closing

Purchasing an auto repair shop is a significant step that requires careful planning, honesty about your goals, and a strong understanding of the business's financial and operational aspects. 

As Eric's journey demonstrates, having the right team, investing in efficient software, and being prepared for unexpected challenges are crucial for success. If you're considering this path, take the time to evaluate your options thoroughly, seek out the necessary training, and build a solid foundation for your new venture. With dedication and the right approach, owning an auto repair shop can be an incredibly rewarding experience.

👉 Ready to grow your automotive business? [Book a personalized Tekmetric Demo Here]

FAQ

More articles

As an auto repair shop owner, you know how important accurate labor times are for locking in your profit margin on labor and growing your business. But how do you find a labor guide that you can trust and that works with your shop’s estimate process?

Switching to a newer labor guide can be tough for some shops. Many shop owners already trust their physical, paper labor guide; they’ve been using it for years! But that guide probably doesn’t include labor times for repairs on newer vehicles—not to mention it takes up a lot of space.

Digital auto repair labor guides are becoming standard across the industry because of how accessible they are and how they can be continuously updated with labor times for newer vehicles.

If you’re still using your old labor guide, or even a digital labor guide that isn’t working for you, it might be time to find a labor guide that will better meet the needs of your shop. Here are some key features to look for to narrow down your search.

A standard automotive repair order form usually isn’t more than a page or two. It contains vital information like the work to be done on a vehicle, any parts to be ordered, and a cost estimate of all the services to be provided.

While traditional auto repair order forms have served as a reliable method for managing repair orders for many years, it is becoming increasingly clear that they are no longer the most efficient or effective option available.

In fact, there are several ways in which the use of manual auto repair order forms may be limiting the potential of your shop.

Choosing the best auto repair software for your shop is essential for staying competitive in today’s digital landscape.  While many shops are adopting digital solutions, the variety of options for the top auto shop software can make the choice overwhelming. To find success, it is important to identify a solution that aligns seamlessly with your business goals and strategy.

What is Auto Repair Shop Software?

Auto repair software is a digital tool shop owners can use to streamline workflows and help with daily tasks like invoices, reporting, and payments. These softwares are designed to make shops run smoother and reduce headaches. Each software has a unique set of features and functionality. This guide was created to help you find the best shop management software and compare and contrast features.

Benefits of Auto Repair Software

Auto repair software can offer a lot of benefits for your shop including:

  • Reduced back and forth with customers through two-way texting.
  • Quicker inspections leading to more vehicles per day.
  • More secure files through cloud-based software versus pen and paper.
  • Automated tasks take less time like parts ordering and repair order creation.
  • Increased visibility of how your business is doing through real-time dashboards.
  • Keep track of customer notes, names, and vehicle history in one place.

All of these benefits improve efficiency in your shop leading to more revenue. Plus, your staff will be able to do more in less time making their lives easier.

Top Shop Management Software Features to Look For

The solution you use in your shop should offer a comprehensive suite of features to streamline operations, enhance your customer experience and increase profitability. These features might take on several forms, so look for options that fall into one of the following five categories:

  • Security Features
  • Convenience Features
  • Trust Features
  • Efficiency Features
  • Expansion Features

Tek-Tip: While features are important, don't forget to calculate cost. Compare if the cost is monthly or yearly and what the ROI will be for your shop. Tekmetric users see a 25% average increase in repair orders within the first 120 days.

Security Features

The best automotive repair shop software is one that prioritizes security. Your shop collects tons of data both internally and externally each day. Not only do you store information on your shop’s productivity and financial performance, but vehicle owners also entrust you with their personal information. In all cases, that information should be stored safely and protected by your software solution. Some key features to look for include:

  • Cloud-based. Cloud-based systems are one of the most secure solutions available. Not only is the data stored in a cloud-based system available to you anytime, anywhere, but it is also regularly backed up to provide an additional layer of protection against unforeseen events like natural disasters or equipment failures.
  • Third-party security certification. Third-party certifications validate a shop management system’s commitment to data protection. Tekmetric recently achieved SOC II Type 2 Compliance, demonstrating its dedication to safeguarding customer data in five areas: security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy.

Convenience Features

When customers have an excellent, convenient experience, they are more likely to return to your shop for future repairs. The best car repair software you can use in your shop helps you personalize the customer experience for your target audience and improve customer communication. Here are some customer-centric features to consider:

  • Digital payment solutions. With features like integrated payments, buy now pay later and text-to pay, customers can pay in a manner that works best for them, allowing them to pick up their car after hours, pay invoices from their office and even complete a payment for their college student from states away.
  • Two-way texting. Two-way texting features can streamline communications, allowing your team to easily text with customers. With two-way texting, you can even designate your shop’s existing landline number as the contact to avoid confusion.
  • Automation. With automation-based features like SmartJobs, your service advisors can create jobs in only one or two clicks, allowing them to focus less on manual tasks and more on interacting with customers.

Trust Features

In the auto repair industry, creating customer loyalty is critical for differentiating your shop and driving business. Your customers will keep coming back if they trust your team and the services you provide. As you search for the best shop management software for your shop, look for a solution that helps you increase transparency and build trust with new and existing customers alike. Some features might include:

  • Digital vehicle inspections. DVIs allow technicians to complete a comprehensive inspection of the vehicle and send customers pictures and videos of any repairs it might need. This strategy helps customers better understand what is happening with their vehicle, making them more likely to agree to necessary repairs.
  • Educational integrations. Some integrations can help educate your customers on the necessity of a repair or how their vehicle should work. With Tekmetric’s integration with MotoVisuals, for example, customers can view animated videos of proposed repairs that explain why these repairs are vital for their vehicle. This creates a seamless experience for your customers while building trust and strengthening the relationship.

Efficiency Features

In addition to providing secure data storage and enhancing your customer experience, investing in auto repair software can also help your mechanic shop run more efficiently. The best auto repair software for you should offer customizable functionality that streamlines your internal processes and workflow to help you finish repairs on time. Here are some features that promote efficiency:

  • Inventory orders. In addition to building the estimates, a comprehensive shop management system can support your team in ordering parts and managing inventory. Tekmetric has created an inventory management solution that enables your technician to order parts as they are completing the repair diagnosis. This streamlines the work order process and removes any potential miscommunications between technicians and managers or service advisors ordering parts, leading to a more accurate and efficient process.
  • Automatic progress updates. Tekmetric automatically updates new notes within a repair order for all team members to view the updates as soon as they are entered. Service advisors can then automatically send these updates to the customer, so the customer remains informed even if the service advisor is occupied with another task. With automatic updates, the customer has a play-by-play of the repair – and they can complete the next task, such as approval or payment, without any back-and-forth over the phone or having to come in person.
  • Mobile App for 24/7 access. A mobile app can help your technicians perform inspections faster and be able to take pictures/videos right from their device. Mobile apps can also help shop owners check on reporting and dashboards while away from their desks.
  • Shop dashboard real-time reporting. Reviewing dashboards in real-time allows you to respond to potential bottlenecks or problems that arise throughout the day. For example, you can review your profitability early in the week and determine if you’re on the right path or if you need to take steps such as calling customers for approvals or following up on declined work to generate more repairs.

Tek-Tip: Unbiased review sites like G2 can be helpful when comparing which software is best for you.

Expansion features

One common mistake shop owners make is buying an auto repair shop management software that only meets their current needs. The best auto repair softwares grow with your business and can integrate with other products.

  • Integrations. Each auto repair shop is unique and has different needs. In addition, each shop will grow and have new emerging needs down the road. Purchase an auto repair shop software that meets your current needs and can integrate with other features you will need later on. Ask fellow shop owners which integrations they find helpful and learn from their success.
  • Multi-Location. If you are a shop owner with a vision to expand into multiple locations, make sure your auto repair software can handle the task. Tekmetric offers multi-shop management where you can view all of your reports in one place and streamline your workflow across locations.
  • New Services and Products. Do you envision your shop offering tires or other products in the future? Not all auto repair softwares are built equal, so make sure your software is up the task.

What is the best auto repair shop software?

The best automotive repair shop software for you is one that allows you to run your business smoothly while also supporting security, convenience and transparency between you and your customers. When your software supports these areas, you will be better poised to streamline your shop’s processes and create a better customer experience – ultimately driving your bottom line.

Choosing a software is a personal decision based on your specific business strategy, budget, customers and team. Fortunately, many softwares have advanced features that can be customized to your goals and needs. These advanced features come at a price and each software has differing pricing plans. Make sure your research includes pricing and what the ROI will be for your shop.

Final Thoughts

When researching the right shop management solution for your shop, look for the right features to meet your needs and workflow. Another expert tip is to utilize unbiased review platforms like G2 to discern which software is best for you. Lastly, network and connect with fellow shop owners and see what they recommend.

How to Choose the Best Auto Repair Shop Software

October 15, 2024

Read time: 3 min

read more